Man turns to internet for advice after self-righteous fiancée rejects prenuptial agreement but asks him to sign hers

To sign or not to sign, that is the question…

If you are engaged, or have ever been engaged, there is a possibility that the subject of prenuptial agreements has come up between you and your partner. They’re not a necessity, so not all couples consider them, but they can be an important precaution to take before getting married. No one ever wants to consider the worst-case scenario when planning to spend the rest of their life with their favorite person, but the reality is that not all couples last forever.

Some people will never get married without signing a prenup first, while others consider them completely out of the question. Then there are some people who to think they would never sign one, until they suddenly find themselves inheriting riches…

A man hit up the Relationship Advice subreddit seeking guidance after her fiancé, who was previously against prenuptial agreements, suddenly decided signing one would be wise. You can read the full story below, as well as some of the responses she received from readers and an interview with Julia Rodgers, CEO of We’d love to hear your thoughts on the prenup in the comments, and then if you’d like to read another one Bored panda article on pre-marital drama, look no further right here!

This man sought advice online after his fiancée quickly changed her mind about prenuptial agreement when she inherited $800,000

Image credits: Ron Lach (not the actual photo)

Image credits: Cathrine Sæther (not the actual photo)

Image credits: throwRA_southparking

To get more information on the subject of prenuptial agreements, we reached out to Julia Rodgers. Giulia is the CEO of and a Massachusetts family law attorney who was kind enough to explain why he thinks everyone should sign a prenuptial agreement before getting married. “A prenuptial agreement allows an engaged couple to contract how they want their income, assets, property and inheritance to be treated,” Julia told Bored Panda. “If you don’t have a prenup, your state law will control how your property is viewed — and you might not like it!”

“All couples should consider a prenuptial agreement, because millennials typically marry later in life, have significant earning potential, often have student debt, may own a business, and are likely to inherit in the future “Julia noted. “The best (and in many cases the only) way to protect these assets is with a prenuptial agreement.” She explained that some of the benefits of having a prenuptial agreement are that it allows couples to categorize which debts should be considered separate, which marital assets should be considered separate, and define how inheritances should be considered.

You’re not likely to have any regrets about signing a prenup if you’re going to remain happily married for the rest of your life, but no couple wants to regret Not have one signed if the relationship goes badly. “If you don’t get a prenuptial agreement before you get married, your assets, income, property, any business you own or hold interests in, as well as inheritance will be dictated by state divorce law in the event of a divorce,” Julia told Bored. Panda . “And you may not like the result! State law does not take into account your personal circumstances, life goals, and relationship with your partner. A prenuptial agreement allows you and your future spouse to decide what works for you, before the wedding, so that a judge who doesn’t know you won’t decide in the future.

Julia also wanted to dispel a couple of common misconceptions associated with prenuptial agreements. “Prenuptial agreements have a stigma, including the idea that they’re an indicator of a future divorce,” she noted. “Not so fast! A prenuptial agreement is strategic planning for a successful marriage, and by talking about finances BEFORE marriage, you’re avoiding the number one reason people get divorced: misunderstandings about money. Discussing financial arrangements before marriage means to be successful in a future relationship.

Julia continued to challenge the notion that prenuptial agreements often only protect the wealthier spouse. “Prenuptial agreements can be protective of both spouses and may appear fairer than the default state divorce law because it allows couples the ability to enter into an agreement that is right for their specific life goals,” she explained. . “A prenuptial agreement can create a more level financial playing field in the event that one party (usually the woman) chooses to retire from work for a few years to raise children or care for a sick family member.”

There’s also an article on HelloPrenup that talks about the gender wealth gap right here if you want to take a look. And if you’d like to learn more about prenuptials from Julia or the rest of her team, or are interested in setting one up with your fiancé, be sure to visit right here.

The man later shared more context about the situation in the comments

Traditionally, prenuptial agreements were mostly for people from wealthy families who wanted to make sure their assets were protected in the event of a divorce. But if both parties in a pair didn’t have much money in the first place, it seemed pointless to sign one. However, in recent years, prenuptial agreements have become less taboo and far more common among the average person getting married. In 2010, a Harris Interactive survey found only that 3% of adults who were engaged or married had a prenuptial agreement. By 2022, that number had jumped to 15%.

Prenuptial agreements are also more common among young people, as a whopping 40% of people aged 18 to 34 who were married or engaged said they signed a prenup. Michael Waters also wrote to piece for the New Yorker examining the steady rise in prenuptial agreements. “Marriage is about love, obviously, but it’s also about personal possessions, and I think that’s really affecting young people’s willingness and desire to sign prenuptial agreements in the first place,” she says.

While a conversation about the prenuptial agreement can be a touchy subject for some couples, it’s important to enter into a marriage with full transparency. Couples have to decide how they want to manage/share their finances, and if they can’t come to an agreement before getting married, it’s likely to be a nightmare if they ever face a divorce. None of us can predict the future, and in a world where nearly 50% of all marriages ends in divorce, it doesn’t hurt to be cautious.

In this particular situation, many readers commented that the woman had finally shown her true colors and that this could be a red flag for her fiancé. Signing a prenup is a wise step to take, and personally, I’d be wary of marrying someone who was adamantly against them. But we’d love to hear your thoughts under the pandas: Have you ever signed a prenup, or would you? Why or why not? Let us know what you would do as this man, so if you’re looking for another article on pre-marital drama, you’ll want to read on. This next!

Many readers have warned the man that this is a huge red flag, noting that it might be wise to get out of the relationship before it’s too late